6 Best MasterChef Seasons Of Our Choice

Posted on by Charlotte Hayes

When it comes to cooking competitions, few shows have captured global attention like MasterChef. Originally launched in the UK in 1990, the franchise has since taken the world by storm, with over 65 countries producing their own versions and broadcasts reaching more than 200 nations worldwide.

While each local adaptation brings something special to the table, today we’re diving into what we consider to be the 6 best seasons of MasterChef USA – a show that’s become a staple of American television. With its 14th season set to air, we’ve had plenty of drama, inspiration, and unforgettable culinary moments. Here’s our list – let us know if you agree!

Why MasterChef Matters

MasterChef is beloved not only for its competitive edge but for showcasing the passion, creativity, and perseverance of home cooks from all walks of life. It celebrates the endless appeal of cooking, and whether you’re a hobbyist or an aspiring professional, there’s something incredibly inspiring about seeing someone follow their culinary dream.

And if you’re chasing your own cooking goals, why not commemorate your journey? A custom cooking medal (such as those from Custom Medals Canada) could serve as a powerful symbol of your hard work and dedication. It makes a thoughtful gift, too – especially for a friend whose heart belongs in the kitchen.

The 6 Best Seasons of MasterChef USA

Season 4 – The Gold Standard

For many fans, Season 4 reigns supreme. Aired in 2013, it delivered some of the most engaging storylines and intense competitions we’ve seen. Judges Gordon Ramsay, Graham Elliot, and Joe Bastianich oversaw a stellar season, ultimately crowning Luca Manfè the winner.

What made this season particularly unique was Luca’s return – he had previously been eliminated but came back to win it all. His victory over runner-up Natasha Crnjac, a stay-at-home mum, was a true underdog triumph and remains one of the show’s standout moments.

Season 3 – The Most Inspiring Season

Close behind is Season 3, which aired in 2012. This season gifted us the unforgettable journey of Christine Hà, the first blind contestant to win MasterChef. Her cooking was nothing short of exceptional, earning her a $250,000 prize and a cookbook deal.

Runner-up Josh Marks also impressed, particularly given his dramatic comeback after being eliminated in episode 12. Returning in episode 14, he clawed his way back to second place – proving resilience pays off. The season’s mystery box challenges and invention tests added even more excitement.

Season 7 – A New Era of Fun

Season 7 takes our third spot for its fresh dynamic and engaging cast. Alongside Gordon Ramsay, Christina Tosi returned as judge, while the third judge’s seat was rotated among celebrity guest chefs. This made for a lively and unpredictable series that kept viewers hooked.

Shaun O’Neale, a DJ, emerged as the winner, impressing with his refined palate and presentation skills. Brandi Mudd, a primary school teacher, was the runner-up. What stood out this season was that none of the top 3 contestants had professional culinary experience – it was all heart and hustle.

Season 5 – Farewell to a Classic Line-Up

Coming in fourth is Season 5, which marked the final season with the original judging trio before Joe Bastianich took a hiatus. Aired in 2014, this season struck a balance between tension and talent.

The winner, Courtney Lapresi, an aerial dancer, dazzled with her creativity and three-course finale meal. She later leveraged her win to open her own restaurant. Elizabeth Cauvel, an advertising executive, and Leslie Gilliams, a stay-at-home dad, completed the top three.

Season 8 – A Bold New Direction

Many might argue that Season 2 deserves this spot, but we believe Season 8 deserves the praise. One of the reasons? The addition of Aarón Sánchez as a permanent judge – a decision that added a fresh, dynamic perspective.

The season’s winner, Dino Angelo Luciano, was a dancer from New York with a big personality and serious culinary skills. His journey from the dance floor to the kitchen was both surprising and inspiring. Runner-up Eboni Henry, an addiction counsellor, and third-place finisher Jason Wang, a high school teacher, rounded out the top.

Season 2 – Where It All Came Together

Of course, we can’t ignore the season where MasterChef USA truly began to hit its stride – Season 2. With the original judges Gordon Ramsay, Graham Elliot, and Joe Bastianich at the helm, this season helped solidify the show’s format and tone.

The winner, Jennifer Behm, a former Miss USA contestant turned realtor, took home the grand prize of $250,000. While she didn’t receive a cookbook deal like her predecessor, she successfully launched her own restaurant and catering business. Adrien Nieto, a California server, came in second after a hard-fought battle.

Final Thoughts

Whether you’re drawn to MasterChef for its dramatic eliminations, its heartfelt backstories, or the jaw-dropping dishes, there’s no denying its impact on food television. Each season brings something unique to the table – but these six stand out in our hearts.

Do you agree with our list? Or do you think another season deserves a spot in the top 6? Let us know your thoughts – and perhaps, which contestant inspired you most to get cooking!

Charlotte Hayes
Latest posts by Charlotte Hayes (see all)